Want Hot Water at Your Kitchen Sink

Want Hot Water at Your Kitchen Sink?

This is one of the best plumbing additions for your home. It brings such comfort and convenience. I had one put in about 3 years ago, and every time that hot water comes out in the kitchen or bath, I am delighted!

When it comes to getting instant hot water at a fixture in your home, two popular solutions are often considered: a recirculation pump with a timer and aqua stat, and an under-sink instant hot water tank. Both options provide the convenience of immediate hot water, but they operate differently and come with unique advantages and drawbacks. In this blog, we’ll compare these systems to help you decide which one suits your needs, budget, and home layout.

Recirculation Pump with Timer and Aqua Stat

A recirculation pump system is designed to keep hot water flowing continuously through the hot water lines in your home. This creates a loop that ensures hot water is readily available when you turn on the faucet. Here’s how it works and what to consider:

How It Works

Want Hot Water at Your Kitchen SinkA recirculation pump connects to your water heater and circulates hot water throughout your plumbing system. The pump is equipped with a timer and an aqua stat:

  • Timer: Allows you to schedule when the pump operates, ensuring that hot water is available during peak usage times, such as mornings and evenings.
  • Aqua Stat: Monitors the water temperature and shuts off the pump once the desired temperature is reached. This prevents unnecessary energy consumption and prolongs the pump’s lifespan.

Benefits

  1. Convenience: Hot water is delivered to faucets and fixtures almost instantly, reducing wait times and water waste.
  2. Water Conservation: By eliminating the need to run water while waiting for it to heat up, a recirculation pump can save thousands of gallons of water annually.
  3. Customizable Operation: The timer allows you to adjust the system to your household’s schedule, maximizing efficiency.

Drawbacks of a Recirculating Pump

  1. Installation Complexity: A dedicated return line is often required to create the hot water loop. This means running a pipe from the furthest fixture back to the water heater, which can be expensive and invasive, especially in existing homes.
  2. Energy Costs: The pump requires electricity to operate, and continuously circulating water may lead to heat loss, increasing energy usage.
  3. Initial Cost: While the pump itself isn’t overly expensive, the cost of installation can add up significantly, particularly if retrofitting is required.

Under-Sink Instant Hot Water Tank

An under-sink instant hot water tank offers a localized solution by heating and storing water directly under a sink. Many people really enjoy having hot water on demand in the kitchen for dishes or in the bathroom for washing up. These small tanks provide hot water on demand without the need to wait for it to travel through your plumbing system.

How It Works

Want Hot Water at Your Kitchen SinkAn under-sink water tank is installed near the faucet where instant hot water is desired. The tank keeps a small volume of water heated and ready to use at all times. When you turn on the tap, the hot water flows directly from the tank, eliminating delays. And you are very happy.

Benefits

  1. Quick Installation: Installation is relatively simple and doesn’t require extensive modifications to your plumbing system. This makes it a cost-effective solution for older homes.
  2. Localized Hot Water: Hot water is available immediately at the specific fixture where the tank is installed, ideal for kitchens, bathrooms, or laundry rooms.
  3. Energy Efficiency: These systems heat a small amount of water, which can be more energy-efficient than heating and circulating water throughout the entire home.
  4. Lower Cost: Both the unit and installation costs are typically lower than those of a recirculation pump system.
  5. Less Space Under the Sink: You do have to make room for the tank. So, while having hot water is simply delicious, you will lose some of your storage area.

Drawbacks

  1. Limited Capacity: The tank can only store a finite amount of hot water, usually 1-3 gallons. This may not be sufficient for heavy water use.
  2. Multiple Units Required: If you want instant hot water at multiple fixtures, you’ll need to install separate tanks, which can increase overall costs.
  3. Maintenance: The tank’s heating element and components may require occasional maintenance or replacement.

Comparing the Two Systems

Now that we’ve outlined the basics of each system let’s compare them across several key factors:

1. Installation

  • Recirculation Pump: Requires running a return line from the furthest fixture back to the water heater, which can be labor-intensive and expensive in existing homes.
  • Under-Sink Tank: Simple to install and doesn’t involve significant changes to your plumbing.

2. Cost

  • Recirculation Pump: Higher upfront costs due to the pump and potential plumbing retrofitting. Operating costs may also be higher due to electricity use.
  • Under-Sink Tank: Lower initial investment and installation costs. Operating costs are limited to the small amount of water being heated.

3. Efficiency

  • Recirculation Pump: This may result in energy loss due to continuous water circulation, even with a timer and aqua stat in place.
  • Under-Sink Tank: Heats a small volume of water, reducing energy waste but limited to the specific fixture.

4. Convenience

  • Recirculation Pump: Provides hot water to all fixtures in the home, making it a comprehensive solution.
  • Under-Sink Tank: Delivers instant hot water to one fixture, which may not meet the needs of a larger household.

5. Maintenance

  • Recirculation Pump: Maintenance may include cleaning the pump and ensuring the system remains free of clogs or mineral buildup.
  • Under-Sink Tank: Occasional maintenance of the heating element and flushing the tank to prevent sediment buildup.

Which Option is Right for You?

The best solution depends on your specific needs and the layout of your home. Here are some scenarios to help guide your decision:

Choose a Recirculation Pump If:

  1. You want hot water available at all fixtures in your home.
  2. You’re building a new home or undergoing significant renovations, making it easier to install a return line.
  3. You’re willing to invest in a higher upfront cost for long-term water and time savings.

Choose an Under-Sink Tank If:

  1. You need instant hot water at a single fixture, such as a kitchen sink.
  2. You’re looking for a budget-friendly, easy-to-install solution.
  3. You live in an older home where retrofitting plumbing is cost-prohibitive.

Conclusion

Both recirculation pumps and under-sink instant hot water tanks offer practical solutions for reducing wait times and improving convenience in your home. A recirculation pump is ideal for whole-home applications, providing hot water to every faucet and fixture. However, it comes with a higher installation cost and potential energy losses. On the other hand, an under-sink tank is a simpler, more affordable option for specific fixtures, though its capacity may be limiting.

You can select the system that best meets your needs by carefully considering factors such as your budget, household size, and hot water usage patterns. Whether you opt for the comprehensive coverage of a recirculation pump or the localized convenience of an under-sink tank, either in the kitchen or bath, both solutions will help you enjoy the luxury of instant hot water while reducing water waste.

Related Links for: Want Hot Water at Your Kitchen Sink?

Categories: Instant Hot Water

Related Posts